Home Up Alans Article Plant Health Health in Crisis Conversion

The following article is from the IFOAM (International Federation of Organic Agricultural Movements) website. Links to their website are provided. A more philosophical outlook on why to work organically you find here.

Reports on Organic Agriculture Worldwide

IFOAM homepage

 

Reasons and arguments for organic agriculture

Below is a table for problems where organic agriculture may be a solution or part of a solution. It should be noted that there may be other solutions that could deliver the same results as organic. One of the main features of organic agriculture is how well it integrates a number of important issues, which means that even if there are other solution to each individual problem below, there are no other solution that to such a large extent is addressing most of the problems facing rural communities at the moment.

Apart from ‘problems to be solved’ there may be other good reasons to introduce organic production. These are more related to opportunities. The most obvious opportunity is consumers demand. The personal satisfaction of the farmer can be another one.

Gunnar Rundgren             IFOAM President/Sweden

Problems to be solved

Solutions / Positive measures

Relevance of organic agriculture

 

 

X= high relevance

(X)= certain relevance

X?=relevance depending on conditions

Health problems caused by pesticides

No  use of chemical pesticides

X

Antibiotics hormones etc. in animal husbandry causing health problems

Improved animal systems

X

Integrating animals  and crops

X

Meeting needs of animals

Alternative disease treatments

X

X

Environmental problems caused by pesticides and agrochemicals

No  use of agrochemicals

X

Pollution caused by animal manure and organic waste products

Integration of animals and crop production

Reduced animal density/self-sufficiency of animal feed

X

Falling bio-diversity in sorrounding environment

No use of agrochemicals

X

No GMO crops

X

Diversified production

X

Falling bio-diversity within agricultural production

Diversity and greater number of  crops

X

No use of agrochemicals

X

More varieties- No GMO crops

X

Integration of animals

X

De-forestation

(not logging related)

Alternative fuels to  wood

X? (biogas)

Changed agricultural practises

X? (on one hand OA emphasise trees, on the other hand it may lead to higher use of agricultural land)

Tree-planting for multiple use (fuel, N-fix, fodder, mulching, fruit)

X

Awareness of population

X (OA and OA consumption linked to higher awareness)

Soil degradation leading to falling yields

Erosion control measures

X (Erosion control in inherent in organic concepts)

Increase of organic matter

Diversification of production system, aforestation, agroforestry

X

Falling productivity in Green revolution agriculture (more pests, resistance etc.)

Better management, soil building, prevention, diversification, varieties, biological control

X

Low profit for farmers

Reduced cost for production

Diversified more market oriented production

X? (in situations with high input prices and comparatively low labour costs)

Increased income

X (if special organic market is available)

Low cost efficiency in inputs

Improved management and technology

Efficient use of local (or on-farm) production resources

X

Innefficient use of natural resources

Integration of animals and crop production

Nutrient balance calculations

Nutrient planning over a rotation period or a production cycle

X

Recycling of nutrients from society

X

Limited water resources

Less pollution of water

X

Improve  water capacity of soils

Soil protection measures

Aforestation, agroforestry, mulching and cover crops

X

Foreign Exchange problems

Increase exports values

X? (depending on if value of increased prices compensate potential loss in volume)

Decrease imports of inputs

X

Environmental requirements from export markets

Environmental certification

Extension and capacitation

Organisation of farmers

X

Limitations in market access

Get competitive advantage

Get access to market information

X

Marginalised small farmers

Increase of production

X? (if traditional farming is not optimal)

Redcued cost for production

X? (in situations with high input prices and comparatively low labour costs)

Increased income

X (if special organic market is available)

Improve technology

X (OA is cheap and accessible)

Farmers organisation

Direct marketing

 

Recycling of nutrients from society

X? (depending on the the quality of the waste products, awareness of society, cleaning processes etc)?

Urban migration leading to poverty and slums

Increase income in rural areas, and decrease money flow from rural areas

Organisation, capacitation

(X)

Local / regional development

Increase income in rural areas, and decrease money flow from rural areas

Increase infrastructure and organisation of rural areas

(X)

Social and cultural degradation

Vitalising old values or creating new values

Increase self-reliance and status of rural areas and populations

X?

Threatened food security

Increase production

Long term higher, short time lower, depending on conditions

Availability of production resources

?

Increase income

Depends on the conditions.

Stable production

X? (pests could cause fluctuations…)

Decrease input dependency

X

Increase diversity –less risk

Soil improvement – more resilience

X

Optimal use of local resources

X

(food safety)

Limit un-safe food

X

Increase consumer awareness

X

(food sovereignity)

Local production

(X)

Local seeds

(X)

Local inputs

X

Increase consumer awareness

X

(social conditions)

Less gaps between poor and rich

?

Democracy, transparency, participation

Organisation,

?

 

 

 
Send mail to info@lindros.co.za with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2002 - 2008 LINDROS Whole Earth Consultants
Last modified: February 15, 2008